Table of Contents

Last Updated: October 11, 2026

Coopersmiths vs The Forge Pub at a Glance

Coopersmiths vs The Forge Pub comes down to what matters most for your night: breadth of selection, atmosphere, or food focus. Both are Fort Collins staples, but they serve different crowds and occasions. Coopersmiths has built a reputation as a brewpub with a solid craft beer program and food menu. The Mayor of Old Town, by contrast, operates as a dedicated craft beer bar with 100 rotating taps, the largest rotating selection in the city, paired with an extensive food menu and modern atmosphere. If you’re serious about discovering new beers, the difference in tap count alone shifts the entire experience. This guide breaks down the real distinctions so you can pick the right spot for what you’re actually looking for.

Interior of a modern craft beer bar with high-top tables, a full bar, and groups of people enjoying drinks and conversation in a relaxed setting
Interior of a modern craft beer bar with high-top tables, a full bar, and groups of people enjoying drinks and conversation in a relaxed setting

Coopersmiths Craft Beer Selection and Tap List

Coopersmith’s operates as a true brewpub, brewing beer on-site and maintaining tight control over its tap list (CooperSmith’s Brewpub). The venue typically features 15-20 taps, with the majority dedicated to their own house-brewed beers. This in-house production model means you’ll consistently find their flagship offerings: their IPA, amber ale, and seasonal rotations that change quarterly. The house beers are designed to pair with their food menu, and regulars often develop loyalty to specific house brews they can count on finding.

The trade-off is clear: depth of discovery versus consistency. If you’re seeking rare imports, experimental styles, or breweries you’ve never encountered, Coopersmith’s limited rotation will cycle through quickly. However, if you prefer knowing what to expect, a reliable IPA that tastes the same every visit, or a seasonal that marks the time of year, the house-focused approach delivers. The on-site brewing also means the beer is fresher than venues relying entirely on distributor inventory.

The food menu is solid pub fare: burgers, sandwiches, and classic lunch and dinner offerings that pair well with beer but don’t push culinary boundaries. This straightforward approach works well for groups where not everyone is a craft beer enthusiast, since the food stands on its own merit rather than requiring adventurous palates.

For regulars and neighborhood visitors, Coopersmith’s house beer program creates a sense of place. You’re not just drinking beer; you’re supporting a local brewery that’s been part of the community for years. That matters to many drinkers.

The Forge Pub Beer Menu and Rotating Options

The Forge Pub takes a different approach. Their beer menu rotates, meaning new taps appear regularly and the selection stays fresh. This creates discovery opportunities, each visit potentially brings unfamiliar breweries and styles. However, rotation also means inconsistency. Your favorite beer from last month might not be on tap this week. The Forge Pub positions itself as a destination for beer exploration rather than a home base for regulars. The food menu here is more ambitious than typical brewpub fare, offering options that go beyond standard bar food. If you’re visiting Fort Collins for a weekend and want to experience what the local craft beer scene has to offer, The Forge Pub delivers breadth.

Food, Atmosphere, and What Sets Them Apart

Here’s where the venues diverge most sharply. Coopersmiths feels like a traditional brewpub, comfortable, familiar, designed for groups and casual hangouts. The atmosphere is relaxed and community-focused, making it ideal for regular meetups or bringing people who aren’t necessarily beer enthusiasts. The food is straightforward: burgers, sandwiches, and classic pub fare that works as a backdrop to drinking.

The Mayor of Old Town operates with a modern, adult-oriented atmosphere. The space is designed for serious beer exploration with a beautiful patio and high-top tables that encourage standing, mingling, and conversation. The food menu is extensive, still approachable. This is a venue where the beer IS the main event, not an afterthought. The locally-owned, family-operated character means the space feels curated rather than corporate. For groups of 15 or more, The Mayor of Old Town offers exclusive experience options, which matters if you’re planning a celebration or private gathering.

The real distinction: Coopersmiths is a brewpub where beer happens to be central. The Mayor of Old Town is a craft beer bar where everything else (food, atmosphere) supports the beer experience.

Pro Tip
If you’re bringing non-beer drinkers, check the food menu carefully. The Mayor of Old Town has broader options, but Coopersmiths’ straightforward pub fare is sometimes safer for mixed groups.

How to Choose a Craft Beer Pub That Fits Your Group

The choice depends on three factors: what you’re drinking for, who you’re with, and what you want to do.

Drink for discovery? The Mayor of Old Town wins. With 100 rotating taps, you’ll find beers you’ve never encountered. Coopersmiths’ curated, house-focused list means less exploration but more reliability.

Visiting for a casual hangout? Coopersmiths feels more like a neighborhood spot. It’s easier to relax, the vibe is familiar, and the food is straightforward. The Mayor of Old Town skews more toward “destination” than “regular Tuesday night.”

Planning a larger group? The Mayor of Old Town explicitly supports groups with exclusive experience options for 15+ people. Coopersmiths can accommodate groups but doesn’t position itself as a group destination.

Want serious food? The Mayor of Old Town’s menu is more ambitious. Coopersmiths is solid but predictable.

Factor Coopersmiths The Mayor of Old Town
Beer Selection House-focused, curated 100 rotating taps
Atmosphere Traditional brewpub Modern, adult-oriented
Food Menu Classic pub fare Extensive, thoughtful options
Group Events Accommodates groups Exclusive group experiences (15+)
Best For Regulars, casual hangouts Beer exploration, celebrations

Location, Hours, and Practical Details

Both venues occupy Fort Collins‘ Old Town district, a walkable neighborhood with street parking and nearby paid lots. Coopersmith’s is located at 5 Old Town Square, steps from downtown shops and restaurants. The Mayor of Old Town sits at 1 Old Town Square, equally accessible and in the heart of the district’s social hub.

Online Ordering →

Operating Hours & Accessibility:
Coopersmith’s typically operates from 11 a.m. to midnight Monday through Thursday, with extended hours (11 a.m. to 1 a.m.) Friday and Saturday, and 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. Sunday. The Mayor of Old Town maintains similar hours: 11 a.m. to midnight weekdays, 11 a.m. to 1 a.m. Friday-Saturday, and 11 a.m. to 11 p.m. Sunday. Both venues are wheelchair accessible with street-level entry and accessible restrooms.

Parking & Walk-In Availability:
Street parking in Old Town is free for the first two hours; metered spots turn over quickly during lunch and evening rush (Downtown Parking Management Updates). Both venues have nearby paid lots (typically $1-$2 per hour) if street parking is full. Walk-in availability varies sharply by day and time. Weekday afternoons (2-5 p.m.) are usually quiet at both venues, with ample seating. Friday and Saturday evenings (6 p.m. onward) fill up quickly; expect 15-30 minute waits for tables during peak hours (7-9 p.m.). Sunday brunch and early afternoon are moderate.

Reservations & Group Planning:
Coopersmith’s accepts walk-ins and small reservations (up to 8 people) for weekday dining but operates first-come, first-served on weekends. The Mayor of Old Town explicitly supports group reservations and offers structured group experiences for parties of 15 or more, which should be booked at least one week in advance. If you’re planning a celebration or team outing, The Mayor of Old Town’s group programming is a significant advantage; Coopersmith’s can accommodate groups but doesn’t market dedicated group packages.

Seasonal Considerations:
The Mayor of Old Town’s patio becomes a major asset from May through September, when outdoor seating extends capacity and creates a more relaxed atmosphere. Coopersmith’s is primarily indoor, which matters during winter or rainy weather, the covered space stays comfortable year-round. If you’re visiting during summer, The Mayor of Old Town’s patio seating adds real value.

Practical Takeaway:
For spontaneous visits, both venues work equally well on weekday afternoons. For weekend evenings or groups larger than 8, plan ahead: call Coopersmith’s to confirm seating, or book The Mayor of Old Town’s group experience in advance. Neither venue requires reservations for individuals on weekdays, but both fill up Friday and Saturday nights.

Which Venue Works Best for Your Night Out

Choose Coopersmiths if: You’re a regular who wants reliable house beers, you’re bringing a mixed group including non-beer people, or you want a traditional brewpub atmosphere where beer is one part of the experience.

Choose The Mayor of Old Town if: You’re a craft beer enthusiast seeking discovery, you’re planning a celebration or group event (15+ people), you want a modern atmosphere with a beautiful patio, or you value an extensive food menu alongside your beer selection.

The honest take: Coopersmiths vs The Forge Pub is really Coopersmiths vs The Mayor of Old Town, and The Mayor of Old Town edges ahead if beer is your priority. The 100 rotating taps, modern space, and explicit group programming create a more intentional experience for serious drinkers. Coopersmiths remains the better choice for casual, consistent, neighborhood-style hangouts.

Both venues deserve visits. They serve different purposes. The question isn’t which is objectively “better”, it’s which matches what you’re actually looking for on any given night.


Fort Collins’ craft beer scene thrives because venues like these offer distinct experiences. If you’re ready to explore a wide rotating beer list with a modern atmosphere built for groups and celebration, The Mayor of Old Town delivers. With 100 rotating taps, an extensive food menu, and exclusive group experience options, you’ll find beers you’ve never tried and a space designed for your next gathering. Visit The Mayor of Old Town to check current taps and plan your visit.

Frequently Asked Questions

How does Coopersmiths compare with The Forge Pub for craft beer selection?

Coopersmiths is known for a strong rotating tap list focused on Colorado craft breweries and regional selections. The Forge Pub offers a variety across styles and breweries, including international options. If you prioritize local Colorado breweries, Coopersmiths leans that direction. If you want broader exploration across beer styles and regions, The Forge Pub’s approach may appeal more. Both rotate regularly, so the specific beers available change weekly.

What should I compare when choosing between two craft beer pubs?

Start with beer selection: Does the pub focus on local breweries or offer national and international options? Check the atmosphere: Is it loud and crowded or quieter and conversation-friendly? Look at food quality and menu breadth, does it go beyond typical bar fare? Consider location and parking. Finally, think about your group size and whether the venue handles larger reservations comfortably. These factors matter more than any single feature.

Which pub has a wider selection of beer styles?

The Forge Pub offers variety across beer styles and breweries from multiple regions. Coopersmiths focuses more on Colorado craft breweries and regional selections. For exploring different styles, IPAs, sours, stouts, lagers, and experimental brews from various producers, The Forge Pub’s approach offers broader exposure. For supporting local Colorado breweries specifically, Coopersmiths aligns better with that goal.

What food options should I look for at a craft beer pub?

Look beyond standard bar snacks. A craft beer pub should offer a full menu with burgers, sandwiches, and entrees that pair well with beer. Check whether they offer vegetarian or dietary options. Both venues offer food, but the breadth of options differs, visit their websites or call ahead to see current menus before deciding.

The owner of this website has made a commitment to accessibility and inclusion, please report any problems that you encounter using the contact form on this website. This site uses the WP ADA Compliance Check plugin to enhance accessibility.