Food menu

Nibbles, Bites, and Snacks oh My

Choo Choo Chicharrones 

Beers favorite snack. Savory, salty, and spicy with a drizzle of hot sauce. Not vegan. Try them! 6

salted pretzel

Salted with love. With Black and Tan Cheese sauce German mustard. 6.50

dirty Chips

A basket of potato chips dirtied up with buffalo sauce and blue cheese dressing. 6

Beer Battered Califlower

In our house made beer batter. Crispy and healthy!  With sauce on the side. 11


Soft pretzel stuffed with jalapeño cream cheese and paired with raspberry jalapeño dipping sauce. 7.50


Fries, truffle oil, shaved parmesan, lemon garlic aioli Parmesan truffle fries. Yes for Real. Eat this basket of decadence. 10


Hangabur and side 

Hangabur with Chez and side

Crunchy Chicken Fingers and side

Four Wings and Side

Macaroni and Cheese

Kid’s Nachos 

Starters and Sharables 

Mason Street Wings 

Your wings and your favorite sauces, including spicy buffalo, BBQ, or whiskey fire sauce. With fresh veggies and dressing.
8 for 15 – 12 for 21 – 16 for 26

Chopped brisket nachos

Potato chips topped with shredded cheese, smoked brisket, fresh onions, jalapeños, and tomatoes. 18

Cheesy Ba’Corn

Fire roasted corn mixed in with our house made beer cheese, bacon, fresh jalapeños, and topped with melted cheese and served with both corn chips and thick cut pub chips for dipping and sharing, or not. 11

Mayor’s Pretzel Feast

Can’t decide? This one will feed the whole ‘office’, or at least get you all started. Comes with one jalapeño cream cheese pretzel, one salted pretzel, salami, mortadella, cheese curds, sliced beer brat, sticks & stones, La Folie beets, olive salad, black and tan beer cheese, raspberry jalapeño sauce, and honey mustard. 32

Nachos Del Mayor

Fresh house fried tortilla chips topped with shredded cheese, black beans, onions, fresh jalapeños, tomatoes, and cilantro. 16

add chicken for 3 bacon 3  slow beef 4  brisket 4  ground beef 4

Chicken tenders

A pile of crispy panko chicken, We’ll bring the sauce. 11

Poudre Valley Poutine

Mayor fries with cheese curds covered in rich roasted beef Guinness gravy.11

Add slow beef for the best you’ve ever had. 15


Three sliders. Choose from buffalo chicken fingers, mini muffaletta, BBQ pork, or Rueben. 11

Beer Hall Favorites 

slow beef stroganoff 

Extra slow braised beef with mushrooms, and a rich cream sauce. Tossed with cavatappi. A staff favorite! 18

Cowboy Ciao 

Chicken sautéed with green peppers, onions, and bacon, with jalapeños and southwest pesto cream sauce tossed in with cavatappi. 19

Switch to gluten free penne for 4

Sheppard’s pie

Lean ground beef browned with thick savory sauce and veggies topped with our smashed potatoes and melted cheese. 18

Fish and Chips

Fresh made Mayor beer battered cod and crispy fries and house made tartar sauce. EVERYDAY! 20


This is the one! Black and Tan cheese sauce with mixed in hatch green chilies, tossed in cavatappi, and topped with queso fresco. 13 Add bacon 3 chicken breast 3 Slow Beef 4

Beer Brat Currywust

The famous and tasty German Favorite!   Two beer brats served with our apple bacon kraut, fries, and house made curry ketchup over all of it. 16

Lighter Bites 

roased beet salad folly style 

A large bowl of arugula and green leaf with roasted beets, quinoa, dried cranberries, and queso fresco. 13 add chicken 3 or ahi tuna 4

Muffuletta Salad

Mixed Greens loaded with ham, salami, mortadella, provolone, and olive muffuletta mix. A salad for sandwich lovers. 16

Wrap it Up! 

Build your own wrap. Pick a meat and a sauce then we’ll take care of the rest in a large flour tortilla with chopped tomatoes and crisp lettuce. 15

Meats: Chicken – grilled or crispy, Chopped Brisket, gyro meat, ahi tuna, sloppy joe, Slow Beef, Shredded pork, cod – crispy or grilled, or beyond ‘burger’.

Sauces: Ranch, BBQ Ranch, BBQ, Buffalo, Bleu cheese, raspberry jalapeño, or any other wing sauce

Two Fisted sandwiches

We use all natural products and make everything we can in house. Served with choice of one side. 

The Mayor Muffuletta 

Fresh from New FoCo. Smoked ham. salami, mortadella, and provolone cheese layered on a ciabatta roll with house made olive salad. Might be the best cold sandwich in all of Colorado. 14

Colorado Cubano 

A toasted ciabatta bun filled with our slow smoked pork then layered applewood pit ham, Swiss cheese and sauced with our Colorado sauce. 15

Slow beef Dip

Juicy extra slow braised beef pulled apart and piled on melted provolone in a hoagie roll. Served with au jus. 18

Avocado chicken sandwich

Our house brined chicken breast grilled and loaded with sliced avocado, pepper jack cheese, and special cilantro sauce. 16

Brewer’s Beef and Brisket Sloppy Joe

A sloppy Joe all grown up. We use all natural ground beef, add in our slow smoked brisket, stir a little beer into our top secret sloppy sauce and pile it on a ciabatta roll with cheddar cheese. The lunch lady is beaming with pride! Who writes this stuff? 16

Klobster Roll 

The ‘k’ is silent 😉 Yes, there’s real lobster, and some other delicious sea food with butter, mayo, celery and loaded into a split top bun. Sink your claws into this delightful treat! Yes, it comes chilled. 16


Your new favorite sandwich.  One of two ways.

Have the traditional-ish with apple bacon kraut, course ground mustard, and Mayor raspberry jalapeño sauce on a pretzel bun.

Or, try it Ooh Mommy style with Ooh Mommy sauce and Mayor slaw on a pretzel bun. Where have you been all my life? Cue the polkas. 16

Hopped up Rueben 

Tender IPA braised corned beef stacked up with apple bacon kraut on thick cut marble rye with Swiss cheese and Colorado sauce. 16

Ooey Gooey Grilled cheese with slow beef

Your choice of white or rye with pepper jack, cheddar, Swiss, and provolone cheese melted and filled with our Slow Beef. 16

buffalo fried chicken 

Our crispy panko chicken fingers sauced with buffalo sauce and topped with our chunky house made blue cheese dressing. 15

Mayor odds, adds, & sides



PTO Fries – Mayor fries tossed in parmesean truffle oil (1 extra)

*Onion Rings – Thick cut spanish onions with beer batter (1 Extra)

*Sweet Potato Fries – sweet and savory sweets (un-coated) (1 Extra)

Cup of green chili – made in house and gluten free

La Folie Beets – a small bowl of our chilled house roasted beets



* These items may be served raw or undercooked based on your specification, or contain raw or undercooked ingredients.
Consuming raw or under-cooked meat, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions

Tavern Tacos 

2 Fish Tacos

Crispy beer battered cod hugged by warm flour tortillas with cilantro sauce, cabbage, and tomatoes 12

3 gyro tacos

Gyro meat in flour tortillas and topped with onion, tomato, and ranch tzatziki sauce. 12

3 chopped briskset tacos 

Smoked brisket in corn tortillas topped with BBQ sauce and Mayor slaw 13

3 beef and briskset sloppy joe tacos

Flour or corn tortillas with our house sloppy Joe filling. Topped with shredded cheese. 12

3 Slow beef tacos

Slow beef in corn tortillas and topped with onions, cilantro, and whiskey fire aioli. 14

3 aHI WON TON FLAT tacos

Seared and chilled ahi tuna on a crispy won ton shell with Mayor slaw on top. 15

3 Spicy Pork Tacos 

Slow smoked pork topped with mango habanero sauce, fresh jalapeños, and red onions. 12

Nearly famous burgers 

Our burgers are all natural Colorado beef, and come with your choice of side.
Swap to chicken breast for free or a Beyond meat ‘burger’ for 3
Add a second beef patty or chicken breast for 3
Switch to a pretzel bun for free, or gluten free bun for 2

Steel Rail fire Burger 

A pile of fire roasted hatch green chilies, pepper jack cheese, and our homemade super hot ghost chili habanero salsa – Addictingly hot! We are not kidding. 16

The mayor Burger

Special secret sauce, choice of cheese, topped off with lutuce, tomato, red onion, and a pickle spear. 15

 Bacon cheese burger 

Juicy all natural Colorado beef burger topped with melted cheese and smokey bacon. 16

Getting Figgy with it

Juicy burger topped with bleu cheese crumbles, smokey bacon and fig jam. This is luxury. 17

Kraut Burger 

Our super juicy burger topped with apple bacon kraut, Swiss cheese, and Colorado sauce. Comes on a pretzel bun and a side of mustard! 16

Nacho Burger

Loaded with black and tan cheese sauce, tortilla chips, fresh salsa, and queso fresco. Yes, it is yours! 16

Railhand burger

Topped with our house made BBQ sauce, smokey bacon, black and tan onion rings, and cheddar cheese. 17

Beyond meat vegan dream 

More at

Tastes great and also happens to be fully veggie based ‘meat’ topped with caramelized onions, sauteed mushrooms, and a vegan hatch green chili ranch on a vegan bun. 17

Mushroom swiss burger

Topped with savory mushrooms and creamy Swiss cheese.16

Smothered Green Chili Burger 

Our spicy smokey green chili poured over your open face burger with pepper jack cheese. Get your fork ready to dive into deliciousness. 16

Mayor odds, adds, & sides



PTO Fries – Mayor fries tossed in parmesean truffle oil (1 extra)

*Onion Rings – Thick cut spanish onions with beer batter (1 Extra)

*Sweet Potato Fries – sweet and savory sweets (un-coated) (1 Extra)

Cup of green chili – made in house and gluten free

La Folie Beets – a small bowl of our chilled house roasted beets



Sweet Endings 

The Mayor’s cookies – Baked with chocolate chips and crisp pretzel pieces. A warm plate of 3 cookies. 6 Add a scoop of vanilla ice cream 2

Chocolate toffee mousse cake – Sweet, creamy, and made with Kalua 8

Rich and fudgy brownie – Gluten Free! Made with dark Honduran chocolate. Comes warm. 5 Add a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream. 2

Toffee Crunch Blondie – Browned butter and whole sugar with chocolate chunks. Warm and chewy. 5 Add a scoop of vanilla ice cream for 2.

You’ll notice 3% Back of House Love added to every bill at The Mayor of Old Town.  100% of this goes to the hardworking folks who prepared your meal today.  Thanks for your support!